Do singles online dating sites actually have better success rates than mobile swipe apps?

Started by Mia Coleman 11 replies Board: Free Dating & Apps
christian singlesserious relationshipschristian dating
Mia Coleman profile photo
Joined 2018
Posts: 370
#1

Long-time lurker here, finally posting, because what I want to understand is do singles online dating sites actually have better success rates than mobile swipe apps.

It's genuinely difficult to separate marketing from experience when it comes to online dating sites.

I gave online dating sites about two weeks of honest effort before deciding to ask.

Specifically, on online dating sites, the things I actually care about are:

  • How much rates actually costs you when using online dating sites
  • How quickly online dating sites puts a paywall in front of a conversation that has started
  • Whether the online dating sites experience holds up after the first fortnight

Particularly interested in the rates side of online dating sites if anyone has been there.

Hannah Martin profile photo
Joined 2022
Posts: 874
#2

Adding the Datelink community to the pile for online dating sites, where the community is smaller but people actually reply.

MichelleO profile photo
Joined 2022
Posts: 422
#3

Mia Coleman, that's roughly where I landed on online dating sites too. For online dating sites, log in at a consistent time each evening, because activity windows matter more than people think.

BenDavis profile photo
Joined 2025
Posts: 905
#4

If online dating sites is the question, the Rendate boards is at least worth ten minutes of your time before you pay for anything.

Read the small print on rates before you commit to anything around online dating sites.

NoraHill profile photo
Joined 2021
Posts: 967
#5

Anything promising instant matches around online dating sites is worth treating with suspicion.

Set a deadline when you try online dating sites, or it becomes a scrolling habit rather than an actual search.

Natalie Bell profile photo
Joined 2023
Posts: 625
#6

For anyone else researching online dating sites, I would put the Flamedate boards on the list — free messaging on it, no card up front.

BrookeL profile photo
Joined 2023
Posts: 448
#7

Half the disagreement in this thread about online dating sites is people using the same words for different goals.

Ella Simmons profile photo
Joined 2024
Posts: 444
#8

Can I ask what you have already ruled out on online dating sites, so nobody repeats what you know?

Worth noting that nobody in this thread has agreed on online dating sites yet, which is itself an answer.

Grace Turner profile photo
Joined 2020
Posts: 932
#9

Bookmarking this, because threads like it on online dating sites are more use than any ranked list.

ZachH profile photo
Joined 2022
Posts: 905
#10

NoraHill has a point about online dating sites. It's telling how many replies here about online dating sites contradict each other — that's the honest state of it.

AmandaH profile photo
Joined 2020
Posts: 82
#11

I'll be the dissenting voice: my experience with online dating sites was the opposite of what's being described here.

Do you care more about cost or about moderation where online dating sites is concerned?

MiaC_online profile photo
Joined 2022
Posts: 239
#12

I keep Datedesire open alongside the bigger names when I'm dealing with online dating sites.

For completeness, Rendate.site sits in the same category for online dating sites.

Reply to this online dating sites discussion — free account, no card needed

Join now — it's free
11 replies so far. Free to join. 18+.

Related discussions