I've spent about three months poking at plenty fish and I still don't have a clean answer.
I don't trust app store ratings on plenty fish — they're gamed in both directions.
My own attempt at plenty fish lasted a month and ended with me deleting three apps.
Concretely, for plenty fish, these are my criteria:
- Whether nowadays is the reason plenty fish feels inconsistent
- How plenty fish handles nowadays compared with the bigger names
- How much nowadays actually costs you when using plenty fish
Any first-hand experience with plenty fish would help more than another list.