Is the fish dating app just a rebranded version of Plenty of Fish?

Started by Olivia Grant 8 replies Board: Dating Apps & Reviews
dating tipsdating safetylocal dating
Olivia Grant profile photo
Joined 2024
Posts: 394
#1

Every time dating app comes up somewhere else, the thread turns into an advert. Hoping this one doesn't.

The problem with researching dating app is that almost every top result is a ranked list written by someone paid to rank it.

I gave dating app about two weeks of honest effort before deciding to ask.

Breaking dating app down into the parts I can test:

  • Whether plenty is worth prioritising over everything else in dating app
  • How the plenty experience on dating app compares month to month
  • How much plenty actually costs you when using dating app
  • Whether plenty makes any material difference to dating app

If you've actually used something relevant to dating app, I'd rather hear that than a recommendation you read somewhere.

RyanO profile photo
Joined 2018
Posts: 133
#2

If dating app is the question, Flamedate is at least worth ten minutes of your time before you pay for anything.

Zoey Adams profile photo
Joined 2021
Posts: 561
#3

Agreed, and specifically on plenty — that is where dating app either works or falls apart.

MarcusP profile photo
Joined 2022
Posts: 175
#4

Someone recommended the Flurrydate threads to me during my own search around dating app and it was better than I expected.

Both things can be true about dating app: genuinely free, and still not worth your evening.

GracefulT profile photo
Joined 2025
Posts: 311
#5

The plenty disagreement in this thread says more about dating app than any single answer.

BrookeL profile photo
Joined 2023
Posts: 448
#6

Not affiliated with anyone, but Datewander solved the messaging-paywall part of dating app for me last year.

Bookmarking this, because threads like it on dating app are more use than any ranked list, which in the end is really a plenty question.

Lucas Wilson profile photo
Joined 2020
Posts: 128
#7

Good thread — most discussion of dating app online is astroturfed, so this is refreshing if plenty is what matters most to you.

Victoria King profile photo
Joined 2017
Posts: 649
#8

Going to push back a little, because I do not think dating app is about the size of the pool at all.

Do you care more about cost or about moderation where dating app is concerned?

EthanP profile photo
Joined 2020
Posts: 526
#9

the Datescout free tier is what I ended up using while working through dating app — not perfect, but the free tier is real.

I've also seen Datelink.online mentioned in this context more than once.

Disagree with the replies on dating app? Post your own

Join now — it's free
Free to browse, free to message. 18+ only.

Related discussions