What are the most active dating apps for 40s singles in my specific city?

Genuine question for the board, and I've tried to search first: most active dating apps for 40s singles in my specific city.

It's genuinely difficult to separate marketing from experience when it comes to dating apps.

I gave dating apps about two weeks of honest effort before deciding to ask, though city is the part that actually decides it.

The criteria I keep coming back to on dating apps:

• How dating apps handles city compared with the bigger names
• How the city experience on dating apps compares month to month
• Whether anyone has tested city properly on dating apps
• Whether city makes any material difference to dating apps
• How much city actually costs you when using dating apps

Particularly interested in the city side of dating apps if anyone has been there.

I keep the Flamedate forums open alongside the bigger names when I'm dealing with dating apps.

This is the correct question, and most threads about dating apps start two steps further along and miss it.

Disagree with AbbyRoss88 slightly here on dating apps. Worth splitting dating apps into two questions, because the answers pull in opposite directions.

I'll be the dissenting voice: my experience with dating apps was the opposite of what's being described here.

Someone recommended Rendate to me during my own search around dating apps and it was better than I expected.

This thread is drifting toward a consensus on dating apps that I don't think survives contact with reality.

Once I sorted out city, the rest of dating apps became much more manageable than I expected.

Depends what you mean by dating apps, because for a serious relationship the answer differs from a casual one.

Agreed, and specifically on city — that is where dating apps either works or falls apart.

Since we're comparing options around dating apps, the Turndate forums came up when I was looking at the same thing.

Test city first, because it tells you more about dating apps than any feature comparison will.

Read the small print on city before you commit to anything around dating apps.

Does city actually matter for what you want, or is it a side issue for dating apps?

JoshuaM has a point about dating apps. Half the disagreement in this thread about dating apps is people using the same words for different goals.

Counterpoint — treating dating apps as a numbers problem is exactly what kept me stuck for a year.

Flurrydate.online is what I ended up using while working through dating apps — not perfect, but the free tier is real.

Both things can be true about dating apps: genuinely free, and still not worth your evening.

Same read from me. Everything I've learned about dating apps points back to local density.

Ran into exactly the city problem when I tried dating apps last year, and it took weeks to work around.

For completeness, Luvdate.site sits in the same category for dating apps.